Evidence Based Wrinkle Reduction
Evidence-Based Medicine in Action
Current attempts at measuring wrinkle reduction mostly rely on static photographs and subjective visual assessments. “With more people turning to this procedure, it is important to have evidence-based ways of improving cosmetic and reconstructive surgical results,” writes senior author Ivona Percec, MD, PhD, director of Basic Science Research and associate director of Cosmetic Surgery in the division of Plastic Surgery at Penn.
Researchers evaluated 14 subjects using a dual camera system and 3D optical analysis. White foundation and black speckle makeup were randomly applied to each patient before and 2 weeks after injection of 20 units of filler in the area between the eyebrows. Movement of the speckles was tracked by the digital camera for analysis. Wrinkles in treated areas were analyzed, resulting in before- and after-treatment heat maps. In the pretreatment heat map, light blue represented wrinkles. Two weeks after treatment, the light blue had been largely replaced with light green and yellow. These new colors were representative of decreased skin compression or wrinkling.
In addition to color changes that signal improvement, the system allows precise measurement of wrinkle reduction. In the study, horizontal compression or wrinkling in the treated area decreased from 9.11% to 2.60% and from 4.83% to 0.83% in the forehead following injection. Average vertical stretch (another form of wrinkling) of the area during brow furrowing decreased from 2.51% to 1.15%, and average vertical stretch in the forehead decreased from 6.73% to 1.67%.
Application of the technique raises the possibility of objectively answering several open questions in cosmetic medicine. For example, in the United States there are currently two other approved formulations for reducing wrinkles. Objective evidence of which formulation provided maximum wrinkle reduction could guide physician and consumer choice in individual cases.
Controversy also exists regarding preparation, dilution, and dosing efficacy of a given toxin, as well as how soon to expect results and how long the results last. Previous investigations of questions such as these largely used static photography with subjective, although validated, scoring scales; these scoring methods could be replaced by three-dimensional speckle tracking photogrammetry. In addition, different dose efficacy in various populations (such as male versus female patients from various age groups) could be determined.
“As new therapies and expanded applications become available for antiaging and the treatment of neuromuscular disorders, this method may make it possible to quantify clinical efficacy and establish precise therapeutic regimens,” Percec says. “Though future studies will need to explore the use of digital image correlation in larger groups, our results are the first to show the modality can be applied to study a range of challenges in plastic surgery.” The procedure may also help quantify how well the injectables work in reducing facial paralysis associated with stroke and Bell’s palsy.